My daughter loves this potty and it has made potty training so easy for us especially since she loves Minnie mouse :)
Click Here For Most Helpful Customer Reviews >>
(This is actually DarkLock "KG~"'s wife.)
For those who don't have time to read a long review, I'll give a simple list of pros and cons.
Pros:
Padding
Handles
Protective pads provided (place on underside of potty to protect your toilet seat)
Pretty little chime (when button pressed)
Easily portable (compared to some other potty seats)
Good for round seats (only okay for elongated...)
Easier to clean than some padded seats
Cons:
quality (questionable)
May shift if used with elongated seat
Does not have any kind of lock (some potty seats can lock onto the toilet seat to insure stability/safety)
Harder/more time consuming to clean than hard seats
Now for the detailed review:
I was really looking forward to receiving this potty seat. The photo makes it look so beautiful.
The first thing I noticed when the potty arrived was the color. In the display photo, the seat looks a little more purple than the actual product. It is closer to the pink color of the handles; although there is purple in it (the castle and leaves are purple). It also looks more shiny and smooth in the picture. (I realize that the color may vary...and also that the shiny look probably had a lot to do with the lighting when the photograph was taken...but it was still surprising to me).
This was disappointing, but not a big deal, since I cared more about functionality than anything else. Which leads me to the next issue...
This particular one was damaged. The seam on the inner part of the seat was torn open (both in the front and the back. I was able to see what looked like cardboard and foam on the inside. I was very surprised to see this (I guess I usually have pretty good luck in avoiding damaged goods).
Even more disappointed now, I went online to find out how to return the item.
On a positive note, I had no problems with Amazon. The product arrived when expected and the return process was pretty much easy and stress free.
That really helped encourage me to try again. Even though the product wasn't as good as I expected, I read in a review that it worked with elongated toilet seats, and I was having the hardest time finding a padded potty seat with handles that fit elongated seats. So, needless to say, I really wanted this to work out.
Once I started the return process (actually more of an exchange...but it was called something else...), Amazon sent me another seat (even before I sent this one back)! Granted, I would be charged for both seats if I didn't return the first potty seat within 30 days...but that seemed reasonable to me.
When the second potty seat arrived, I was relieved to see that the seams were good. As for the song that plays when the button is pressed, it's more like a chime; just a short melody. I know a reviewer mentioned this and thought his seat may have been defective, but both of the ones I received were like this. Now to the last issue...
A different reviewer said this works with elongated seats. I guess that's true, as long as you're using a hard seat (like you're supposed to) and don't mind it shifting from front to back a bit. If your child hasn't had any previous negative experiences with the potty/a potty seat, this amount of movement might not be a problem. However, due to...experiences which I (and the instructions) was against...my daughter became afraid of using the potty.
(I was asked to use this on top of a padded toilet seat. Do not do this. It is unsafe/unstable. Every time I had to shift my daughter or she moved on her own, the seat moved. One time the seat ended up on the floor and my daughter's foot almost touched toilet water. Yuck! And sadly, during all the commotion, I unintentionally pressed the button. So after that, to my daughter, the pretty sounding melody actually became haunting. =(
On a side note: With a different potty seat, a toy and treats for incentives, she's doing much better. She'll walk to the potty herself when I ask her to and try to climb onto it on her own! Haha (she's tall for her age, but still only 15½ months...and we don't have a step stool for her, so you can imagine, for her to actually succeed in her efforts would be quite a feat.)
Anyways, since we would need to purchase a hard (elongated) toiled seat regardless...we found one that closes quietly and has a child seat attached (there is a magnet in the child seat and the lid of the toilet, so you don't have to worry about the child seat resting on your back. A definite plus! =))
It has no padding and no handles...but I don't ever have to worry about it moving around (and neither does my daughter).
I'll admit, my rating is influenced by my first experience (which may have just been a rare defective product), but overall I feel my rating is fair.
On another side note, I'll be keeping the (undamaged) First Years Disney Potty Seat so that when my daughter is further along with her training I'll have something to take with me for use in public washrooms. Most of them have hard seats and many are round...so I'm sure I'll get some use out of it then. In the meantime, it's hibernating in the closet. =)
~DarkLock's wife (MG)
Best Deals for The First Years Magical Sounds Soft Potty Seat
My daughter loves this, every time she is done going she pushes the cheer button and smiles. Hey if it entertains and is a good fit for the toilet and her, there is not much I could ask for.
Honest reviews on The First Years Magical Sounds Soft Potty Seat
Bought this after my son decided to wear his cheap one on his head, bless my child, and it got stuck and had to be cut off... he loves mickey mouse so i thought this would be great... He LOVES it... and has actually been trying to go to the potty again.... only thing I wish is that it said/sang more then "hip hip horray!"
Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for The First Years Magical Sounds Soft Potty Seat
I bought this is the store and the sounds are cool, but I noticed when I got it, the opening is smaller than a different potty seat we already had.
This one is cushier, and "cooler" looking, but my son has developed a sensitivity in his privates. And in the last day or two he refuses to sit on it.
I think it's because when you sit on it, or press down on it with your hand, you'll notice the plastic pushes into where the child's flesh would be.
So I think the plastic is rubbing against his tender flesh and hurting him. This thing is going back to the store! Not worth the money, or the potential pain it may cause your boy child.
